Position Paper: Mayor's Views on Boats and Docks

Dear Friends and Neighbors,

Before you read my position paper, let me bring you up to date as of the most recent board meeting. The Board has withdrawn the draft local law on the length of docks and boat size because the trustees have not agreed on what features of the existing law to modify.

Position Paper

The lakes in our community serve as sources of recreation and vital drinking water resources. We must carefully consider the impact that all manufactured elements have on the beauty and preservation of our lakes and the delicate balance of mammals, birds, reptiles, amphibians, and fish they support. Reflecting upon when these lakes existed naturally, free from homes, lawns, gardens, built structures, dams, and other human interventions, is essential. 

By acknowledging the original natural state of the lakes, we can better appreciate the need for responsible stewardship and the importance of minimizing the adverse effects of human activities. We must be mindful of the cause-and-effect relationship between actions, our lakes' well-being, and the diverse wildlife that depends on them. Striking a balance between development and conservation is crucial to maintaining our lake's integrity and natural beauty while ensuring our community's sustainability and use.

As we move forward, we must continue to prioritize environmental considerations and make informed decisions that protect the ecological health of our lakes. By adopting sustainable practices, promoting responsible land and water management, and engaging in ongoing dialogue with experts and stakeholders, we can strive to preserve the pristine nature of our lakes for generations to come. I am committed to working with residents, environmental organizations, and local authorities to ensure our lake's long-term health and preservation and its surrounding ecosystems.

During my first term as mayor, our Board made essential decisions regarding expanding docks and moorings at The Tuxedo Club to accommodate additional boats. We also supported the expansion of The Village Boat Club, increasing the number of available docks and boats and recognizing its significance as a critical asset to our community, with 70 members. The Local Law limiting dock size and boat length to 10 and 20 feet was approved by a prior board. Our Board is considering revising this law, but our discussions are still in the early stages. We are carefully considering various factors, including the maximum length of docks and boats allowed by waterfront property owners on the big lake only, exploring restrictions on new electric propulsion systems, safer battery technology, top speed, and innovative electric-powered boats. Many of these boats are longer than 20 feet.

We recognize that in marinas and waterfront dockages worldwide, docks are often designed to match or exceed the length of boats. This ensures personal safety, prevents damage to the boat's hull, and enables proper tying and cleating. It also provides access to clean the entire boat safely and efficiently after each use. But that does not mean longer docks and boats translate to a lake our size. While we have engaged in debates during our scheduled board meetings and public hearings, we acknowledge that we have only scratched the surface of these complex issues. We value the opinions and input of residents and experts and are eager to engage in a comprehensive debate encompassing this question's aspects above. I, the mayor, and the Trustees must approach this issue with an open mind, considering all points of view. 

The Board firmly believes that making a definitive decision before hearing all sides and gaining a deeper understanding would be irresponsible. My vote is just one among five duly elected officials on the Board, and we will each vote independently on this issue. It is crucial that everyone who wishes to speak is heard and that we hear from all sides before reaching a confident decision. In line with what occurred in 2005-2007, The Tuxedo Club and The Village Boat Club may apply for additional docks and boats. We want to be prepared and open-minded if an application occurs on our watch. We will approach these matters through the lens of maintaining the peace and tranquility the residents are accustomed to, honoring the historical significance of our park, and recognizing that as Tuxedo Lake serves as our reservoir, all our decisions will be subject to government agency regulations and permits. 

I am fully committed to ensuring that the deliberations on these matters are thorough, inclusive, and mindful of the best interests of our community and its natural resources, and I will vote accordingly.

Sincerely,

Mayor Mac